Coaching Call: A Membership for Catholic Moms
- Last updated on: November 24, 2025
This post may contain affiliate links which means we may receive a commission if you purchase through our links. Please read our disclosure for more info.
Mary, an Etsy seller in the Catholic niche, discusses her journey of selling machine embroidery products and transitioning to selling printables. She shares her desire to move off Etsy and reach her Catholic clientele. The conversation explores the idea of Mary becoming a Catholic influencer and the challenges she faces in feeling like a thought leader. They discuss the potential of creating lifestyle content, such as home decorating and holiday activities, to attract and engage her audience. The conversation also touches on the possibility of launching a membership and the importance of understanding her audience’s needs and preferences.
Chapters
00:00 Introduction and Background
01:51 Clearly Defined Niche and Transitioning from Etsy
03:36 Exploring the Idea of Becoming a Catholic Influencer
08:00 Creating Engaging Lifestyle Content
13:07 Launching a Membership for Catholic Homeschoolers
21:54 The Power of Facebook Groups and Community Building
26:18 The Benefits of a Membership Model
28:21 Specific Target Audience
31:21 Product Variety
35:28 Starting with a Physical Product
38:40 Managing a Community
43:37 Dealing with Success and Failure
46:25 Fear of Success
48:34 Sharing Digital Files and Copyright
51:13 Challenges of Customer Behavior
